He didn’t just feel like he was a target, he was a target, although he didn’t know it, nor did he understand it, especially since had tried long and hard to do everything right. It all had crumbled so fast. First came the economic collapse, his ranching business was raided and destroyed by a wildfire. Then all of his children were killed in a tornado. Next came the collapse of his health, which was followed by his wife giving up on him and his friends accusing him of some underlying transgressions that caused it all. In his pain, anguish, confusion, and grief, Job cried, “Why wasn’t I born dead? Why didn’t I die as I came from the womb? Why was I laid on my mother’s lap? Why did she nurse me at her breasts? Had I died at birth, I would now be at peace. I would be asleep and at rest” Job 3:11–13 (NLT).
“Why me?” “Why is this happening to me?” “It’s too much to bear.” “It does not feel right or fair?” “I just don’t understand, God!”
We fear what happened to Job: The things beyond our control. Natural and human evil engulfing us. Poverty, a life of humiliation – losing what we worked hard for. Death, a life of grief – losing those we love the most. Pain, a life of dependency – losing our health. Loneliness, having to defend ourselves – those we trust turning on us. Randomness, our doing good not paying off – not being able to figure things out.
“Why me (or us)?” is often accompanied by, “What did I do to deserve this?” Job’s friends thought that question had only one possible answer, “Think Job, you must have done something wrong!” Which must have been quite a big wrong considering the consequences Job was suffering. His friends’ theological calculations of, bad outcomes must have personal sinful causes just didn’t add up. Long before they asked, “What did you do?” Job had already wracked his brain in search of what he might have done wrong to deserve all this, and he couldn’t find anything.
We are more like Job’s friends than we’d like to admit. We live in a culture of “Karma” thinking – doing good or evil is always linked to being rewarded with good or evil. In Christian circles, this same thinking is dressed up in the various formulas of the prosperity gospel and health and wealth preaching. The problem is that joining the theological camp of Job’s friends never adds up to real life. It forgets that we live in a sinful, broken world with real evil and satanic powers, which/who don’t give a hoot about how much you and I have in our doing good or faith account. The reasoning of Job’s friends was as faulty then as it is now, and it is of little value and comfort when we find ourselves in that dark and painful corner of life where we cry, “Why me?”
Before Job’s life and circumstances unraveled, before he asked, “Why me?” God had had a conversation with satan about Job (Job 1:6-12). “Why not him?” God asked.
“You’ve been protecting him,” satan shot back.
True, but have at him,” God permitted, and satan did.
What a difference, Job’s question on earth was, “Why me?” but preceding it, the question in heaven coming from God’s lips was, “Why not him?”
Our, “Why me?” often implies, “It shouldn’t be me, this must be a mistake,” especially when it doesn’t add up, when there is no discernable sin or lack of faith.
“Why not him/her?” “Why me?” “Why not me?” if we are as serious about serving God like Job, about following Christ like Paul, and walking in the footsteps of the saints throughout the ages, we will have to wrestle ourselves through these questions. Begin with looking at Jesus. He is the first in a long line of faithful Why-not-me servants of God. When no one else in all of heaven and eternity was found to save sinners like you and me, by embracing humiliation, sacrifice, suffering, and death, Jesus said, ‘Why not me!” Consider the Apostle Paul, who pleaded with God to heal him but was given a “request denied” three times, and was instead told by Jesus, “My grace is all you need. My power works best in weakness” 2 Corinthians 12:9 (NLT). Hearing this Paul was faced with making a major adjustment in his thinking, his theology, his outlook, and the way he processed his circumstances. He needed to move from “Why me?” “This shouldn’t be me!” to “Why not me?” and he did. Here is how he responded, “So now I am glad to boast about my weaknesses, so that the power of Christ can work through me.”
May God grant you and me to never get stuck in the “Why me?” and may He help us to embrace the “Why not me?” by living out of Christ’s sufficient grace and our trust in sovereignty, greatness, goodness, power, and wisdom of God.
To God be all glory. Love you, Pastor Hans